Justin tried to make a pass at Mila, 27, while the two were filming Friends With Benefits, using the angle that he and Jessica were secretly over. “Mila knew he had a girlfriend and made it clear it wasn’t going to happen,” says a source close to Mila. Those close to Justin are echoing the same story. “He tried every trick in the book, but Mila is not attracted to him,” says a Justin source.
Mila was not the only one either, with Justin’s relationship with Perfect Couples star Olivia coming to light late last year and photos of him and ex Cameron flirting on the set of Bad Teacher making the rounds last spring.
Jessica was aware of these stories says a pal, but never believed any as there were no incriminating photos. “If Jessica ever had proof that he had cheated, she would have left immediately,” says a friend. Given the number of stories that are emerging about the southern charmer, it seems like Jessica is better off without him!
So HollywoodLifers, which of Justin’s three ladies should he try and date?